Quick Answer: On intermediary vs export of services, the Rajasthan High Court held that an intermediary requires three parties, so services rendered only to the foreign parent IDP Australia are export of services. Both writ petitions were allowed and the IGST refund claims remanded for payment with interest within four weeks.
In IDP Education India Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. (2025:RJ-JP:35572-DB), the Rajasthan High Court decided the intermediary vs export of services question in favour of the taxpayer (paras 7–8). A Division Bench of Chief Justice K.R. Shriram and Justice Maneesh Sharma held that an "intermediary" requires three parties, and services rendered only to IDP Australia qualify as export (para 7). Both writ petitions were allowed and the IGST refund claims remanded for payment with interest within four weeks (paras 11–12).
Headnote: Intermediary vs Export of Services
IGST Act, 2017 – Sections 2(6), 2(13) and 16(3)(b) – CGST Act, 2017 – Export of services – Intermediary – Student recruitment services sub-contracted by foreign parent – Principal-to-principal basis – Refund of IGST on zero-rated supply – CBIC Circular dated 20.09.2021 – Article 226
Held: (i) Refund of IGST paid on the supplies follows unless the petitioner is an "intermediary"; the tax-inclusive fee clause does not defeat zero-rating (paras 5–6).
(ii) The services were rendered to IDP Australia under a specific contract; only two parties were involved (para 7).
(iii) For someone to be an "intermediary", there must be three parties to the arrangement (para 7).
(iv) The petitioner had no say in admissions and no contract with foreign universities or students (para 8).
(v) The Bombay High Court ruling and the CESTAT order in the petitioner's own case were followed (paras 7, 9).
(vi) Having been treated as an exporter in other jurisdictions, the department could not take a different view; refund with interest in four weeks (paras 10–12).
(paras 2–12)
Case Details: IDP Education India v. Union of India (2025:RJ-JP:35572-DB)
Final Outcome: Both writ petitions allowed; matters remanded to the Adjudicating Authority to process the refund claims and pay the refund with applicable interest within four weeks of uploading; no order as to costs (paras 11–12).
Case: IDP Education India Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
Neutral Citation: 2025:RJ-JP:35572-DB
Case No.: D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9933/2024, connected with D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9967/2024
Court: Rajasthan High Court, Bench at Jaipur (Division Bench)
Date of Decision: 4 September 2025
Bench: Chief Justice K.R. Shriram (author) and Justice Maneesh Sharma
Relevant Acts & Sections: Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 – Sections 2(6), 2(13) and 16(3)(b); Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017; CBIC Circular dated 20.09.2021; Constitution of India – Article 226
Impugned Order: Orders of the Original and Appellate Authorities (Deputy Commissioner, CGST Division-H, Jaipur and Joint Commissioner (Appeals), CE and CGST, Jaipur) denying export status and IGST refund for 2019-20 and 2020-21 (paras 2, 3.4)
Counsel: Mr. Prasad Pranjape with Mr. Nitin Jain for the petitioner; Mr. Sandeep Pathak with Mr. Palash Gupta for respondent Nos. 1 to 3; Mr. Bharat Vyas, AAG, assisted by Ms. Niti Jain Bhandari for respondent No. 4.
Source: Rajasthan High Court (official website)
Key Holdings of the Rajasthan High Court
- The only question was whether the services were "intermediary" services or "export" (para 2).
- A tax-inclusive fee clause in the agreement does not, by itself, disentitle the petitioner to zero-rated refund (paras 5–6).
- "For someone to be called an 'Intermediary', there needs to be existence of three parties" (para 7).
- Services rendered only to IDP Australia under a bipartite arrangement qualify as export (paras 7–8).
- The petitioner had no say in the final admission decision and no contract with universities or students (para 8).
- The Court respectfully agreed with the Bombay High Court in the petitioner's own case (paras 7, 9).
- When the petitioner is treated as an exporter in other States, the department cannot take a different view (para 10).
Brief Facts of the Case
The petitioner is the Indian subsidiary of IDP Education Ltd., a listed Australian company (IDP Australia) (para 3). IDP Australia has agreements with foreign universities to assist students with enrolment and is paid a percentage of the student's fee (para 3).
Under a separate service agreement, the petitioner provides placement, course information, counselling and enrolment services to students for IDP Australia (para 3.1). IDP Australia remains the final authority on admission and pays the petitioner 77% of the application processing fee (para 3.1). The arrangement is on a principal-to-principal basis, akin to sub-contracting (para 3.2).
The petitioner treated its services as export under Section 2(6) of the IGST Act and claimed refund of IGST on zero-rated supply under Section 16(3)(b) (para 3.3). The Original and Appellate Authorities held the services to be intermediary, with place of supply in India, and denied refund (para 3.4).
For April 2014 to September 2015, CESTAT had held on 28.10.2021 that the petitioner was not an intermediary (para 3.5). The petitioner invoked Article 226, citing, among other grounds, the absence of the GST Tribunal (para 3.4).
Issues Before the High Court
- Whether the petitioner's services to IDP Australia in 2019-20 and 2020-21 are "intermediary" services or "export" of services (para 2).
- Whether the tax-inclusive fee clause in the agreement bars the refund of IGST on zero-rated supply (paras 5–6).
- Whether the department could take a view different from the CESTAT and the Bombay High Court in the petitioner's own case (paras 7, 9–10).
Court's Findings and Reasoning
Petitioner's case (para 4): Under Section 2(13), an intermediary arranges or facilitates supplies between two or more persons, and excludes one who supplies on its own account (para 4(a)). CESTAT, on the same agreement, held the petitioner was not an intermediary, and the Revenue accepted that order (para 4(b)). The Bombay High Court had applied that reasoning to GST, and refund was sanctioned on 04.06.2025 (para 4(c)).
Revenue's case (para 5): The department relied on Clause 1.3(b) of the agreement dated 01.07.2017 (para 5). It provides that fees are inclusive of any tax payable in India, including GST, so the supply was not zero-rated under Section 16(3)(b) (para 5).
Tax-inclusive clause rejected (para 6): The Court did not accept this submission. The petitioner is entitled to refund of IGST paid "unless petitioner falls under the category of 'Intermediary'" (para 6).
Three-party test (para 7): The services were rendered to IDP Australia under a specific contract, with "Not more than two parties" involved (para 7). An intermediary requires three parties, so the petitioner "cannot be called as 'Intermediary'" (para 7).
No role in admissions (para 8): The impugned order wrongly concluded that the petitioner arranged placement between universities, IDP Australia and students (para 8). The petitioner had no say in admissions and no contract with universities or students (para 8).
Bombay High Court followed (paras 7, 9): The Court "respectfully" agreed with the Bombay High Court in the petitioner's own case (para 7). That judgment noted that only the agreement's periodic renewal differed, and the CBIC Circular of 20.09.2021 confirmed the intermediary law is broadly unchanged (para 9).
Consistency across jurisdictions (para 10): As the petitioner had been treated as an exporter in other State jurisdictions, there was "no reason" for the respondents to take a different view (para 10).
Application to facts (paras 11–12): The services qualified as export, as held by CESTAT and the Bombay High Court (para 7). Both petitions were allowed and the refund claims remanded for payment with interest (paras 11–12).
Final Outcome and Directions
- Both writ petitions were allowed (para 11).
- The matters were remanded to the Adjudicating Authority to process the refund claims in terms of the order (para 12).
- The refund is to be paid with applicable interest within four weeks of the order being uploaded (para 12).
- There was no order as to costs (para 11).
Legal Principle Laid Down
Under Section 2(13) of the IGST Act, an intermediary arranges or facilitates supplies between others and requires a three-party arrangement. A supplier rendering services on its own account only to a foreign recipient, under a bipartite principal-to-principal contract, is not an intermediary. Such services qualify as export under Section 2(6), and IGST paid is refundable under Section 16(3)(b) (paras 6–8).
Precedents Relied Upon
- IDP Education India Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors., 2025 (5) TMI 729 (Bombay High Court) – Followed – Petitioner not an intermediary; CESTAT reasoning applies to GST; refund with interest. Discussed at paras 4(c), 7, 9.
- CESTAT Order dated 28.10.2021 in the petitioner's own case (service tax period April 2014–September 2015) – Relied upon – Services not intermediary; export status upheld. Discussed at paras 3.5, 4(b), 7.
- CBIC Circular dated 20.09.2021 – Relied upon – Scope of intermediary broadly unchanged between service tax and GST. Discussed at paras 3.5, 4(b), 9.
Important Paragraphs of the Judgment
Verbatim extracts from the judgment. For the full text, refer to the judgment PDF below.
Para 6: "We cannot accept this submission of Mr. Pathak because it is quite clear that petitioner will be entitled to refund of IGST paid unless petitioner falls under the category of "Intermediary"."
Para 7: "Not more than two parties are involved in this arrangement, namely, petitioner and IDP Australia. For someone to be called an "Intermediary", there needs to be existence of three parties in the contract, in the absence of which, petitioner cannot be called as "Intermediary"."
Para 8: "Petitioner has no say in the final admission process nor do they have any contractual arrangement with the Foreign Universities or the students and hence, their services are only rendered to IDP Australia under a bi partite arrangement."
Para 10: "In view of the above, when petitioner has been considered as an exporter in other State jurisdictions, there is no reason for respondents to take a different view before us."
Para 12: "The matter is remanded to the Adjudicating Authority for processing the refund claim in terms of this order and pay the refund amount along with applicable interest within a period of four weeks from the date this order is uploaded."
Practical Impact of the Ruling
- For Indian subsidiaries of foreign groups: Services sub-contracted by the parent and rendered only to it can be export, not intermediary (paras 7–8).
- For education and recruitment service providers: Having no say in admissions and no contract with universities or students was decisive (para 8).
- For refund claimants: A tax-inclusive fee clause does not by itself defeat a zero-rated refund (para 6).
- For practitioners: Favourable orders in the taxpayer's own case in other forums and States carry strong weight (paras 7, 9–10).
- For the department: Refunds in such cases must be processed with interest within the time fixed by the Court (para 12).
FAQs on Intermediary vs Export of Services
1. What did the Rajasthan High Court hold in IDP Education India v. Union of India?
It held that the petitioner's services to IDP Australia were export of services, not intermediary services. Both petitions were allowed and the IGST refund ordered with interest within four weeks (paras 7, 11–12).
2. When is a supplier an intermediary under the IGST Act?
The Court held that an intermediary requires the existence of three parties. With only the petitioner and IDP Australia involved, the petitioner could not be an intermediary (para 7).
3. Does a tax-inclusive fee clause bar the IGST refund on export?
No. The Court rejected this argument and held the refund follows unless the petitioner is an intermediary (paras 5–6).
4. What role did earlier rulings in the petitioner's own case play?
The Court agreed with the Bombay High Court and the CESTAT, which had held the petitioner not an intermediary. It also relied on the CBIC Circular dated 20.09.2021 (paras 7, 9).
5. Within what time must the refund be paid?
The Adjudicating Authority must process the claim and pay the refund with applicable interest within four weeks of the order being uploaded (para 12).
Keywords: intermediary vs export of services, IDP Education India v. Union of India, 2025:RJ-JP:35572-DB, D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9933/2024, Section 2(13) IGST Act, Section 2(6) export of services, Section 16(3)(b) IGST refund, zero-rated supply, CBIC Circular 20.09.2021, principal-to-principal sub-contracting, GST refund lawyer, Rajasthan High Court, Chief Justice K.R. Shriram
Related on LegalTaxGuru
- More High Court judgments on GST and indirect tax
- GST articles and updates
- No Filing-Date Bar on Pre-18.07.2022 Inverted Duty Refund – Shree Arihant Oil v. Union of India
Download Judgment PDF – IDP Education India v. Union of India
Source: Rajasthan High Court (official website).
Read more: Rajasthan High Court · GST · Export of Services · Indirect Tax