Quick Answer: "Sharbat Rooh Afza" is classifiable as a "fruit drink" under Entry 103 of Part A of Schedule II of the Uttar Pradesh Value Added Tax Act, 2008 and is taxable at 4%, not at 12.5% under the residuary entry in Schedule V. The Supreme Court held that a licence under the Fruit Products Order describing the product as a "non-fruit syrup" does not control a fiscal entry, that the Revenue failed to prove the product fell outside the specific entry, and that the fruit content, not the 80% sugar syrup, gives the product its essential character. Refund or adjustment of excess tax was ordered for 01.01.2008 to 31.03.2012.
In M/s Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories v. Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P. (2026 INSC 195), the Supreme Court held that regulatory classification under food safety law cannot by itself govern an undefined fiscal entry, and that the common parlance test must rest on objective material of commercial understanding, which the Revenue did not produce (paras 15–16, 20–22). Applying the essential character test, the Court found that invert sugar syrup is merely a carrier and preservative while the fruit juice and distillates give the product its beverage identity, and that inclusive Entry 103 prescribes no minimum fruit content (paras 24–27). With similar entries applied at concessional rates in other States, at least two plausible views existed, and the one favouring the assessee prevailed (paras 33–37). A Bench of Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice R. Mahadevan allowed the appeals (paras 40–41).
Status: Allahabad High Court judgments dated 02.07.2018 in Sales/Trade Tax Revision No. 617 of 2012 and connected revisions, and dated 03.08.2022 in Sales/Trade Tax Revision Defective No. 38 of 2022, set aside; Rooh Afza held taxable at 4% under Entry 103; consequential refund or adjustment ordered; appeals allowed (paras 2–2.1, 40–41).
Headnote: VAT Classification of Rooh Afza as Fruit Drink
Uttar Pradesh Value Added Tax Act, 2008 – Schedule II, Part A, Entry 103 – Schedule V, Entry 1 (residuary) – Fruit Products Order, 1955 – Clause 11 – Central Excise Tariff, Chapter 21, Note 3 ("sharbat") – Classification – "Fruit drink" – Sharbat – Common parlance test – Burden of proof on Revenue – Essential character test – Rule 3(b) – Inclusive entry – Residuary entry – Two plausible views – Interpretation favouring assessee.
Held: (i) A fiscal statute must be interpreted in its own language; regulatory enactments such as the FPO or FSSAI standards operate in a distinct domain and are not determinative for tax classification unless the taxing statute adopts their definitions (paras 15–16).
(ii) "Fruit drink" is undefined in the UPVAT Act, so the common parlance test applies, based on tangible material such as composition, product literature, label, character and use; the authorities wrongly substituted the manufacturing licence and a regulatory clarification for evidence of commercial perception (paras 17–20).
(iii) The burden of proving classification under a residuary or different entry lies on the Revenue; here it produced no trade enquiry, consumer survey or market evidence, and failed to discharge that burden (paras 21–22).
(iv) Under the essential character test, invert sugar syrup (about 80% by volume) is only a carrier, sweetener and preservative; the fruit juice and distillates impart the product's beverage character, which governs classification (paras 24–25).
(v) Entry 103 is inclusive and prescribes no minimum fruit content, so no percentage requirement can be read into it; "fruit drink" covers sharbat preparations intended for dilution, and a product with a reasonable claim to a specific entry cannot be pushed into the residuary entry (paras 27–32).
(vi) Concessional treatment of the same product under similarly worded entries in Delhi, Gujarat, West Bengal, Madhya Pradesh and Andhra Pradesh shows at least two plausible views, and the interpretation favourable to the assessee must prevail (paras 33–37).
(paras 15–41)
Case Details: Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories v. Commissioner, Commercial Tax (2026 INSC 195)
Final Outcome: Appeals allowed; "Sharbat Rooh Afza" held classifiable under Entry 103 of Schedule II, Part A of the UPVAT Act and taxable at 4%; consequential relief including refund or adjustment of excess tax ordered; no costs.
Case: M/s Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories v. Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P.
Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 195
Case No.: Civil Appeal Nos. 2557–2578 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 6074–6095 of 2019), with Civil Appeal No. 2579 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (C) No. 16125 of 2022)
Court: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction) – Reportable
Date of Decision: 25 February 2026
Bench: Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice R. Mahadevan (author)
Relevant Acts & Sections: Uttar Pradesh Value Added Tax Act, 2008 – Schedule II, Part A, Entry 103 and Schedule V, Entry 1; Uttar Pradesh Trade Tax Act, 1948; Fruit Products Order, 1955 – Clause 11; Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 – Chapter 21, Note 3; Rule 3(b) of the Rules for the Interpretation of Tariff Entries / HSN
Impugned Orders: Common judgment dated 02.07.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Sales/Trade Tax Revision Nos. 617 of 2012 and 21 connected revisions, and judgment dated 03.08.2022 in Sales/Trade Tax Revision Defective No. 38 of 2022, affirming the Commercial Tax Tribunal, Ghaziabad (paras 2–2.1)
Source: Supreme Court of India
Key Holdings of the Supreme Court
- Food-law licensing categories, such as "non-fruit syrup" under the FPO, do not control the meaning of an undefined entry in a taxing statute (paras 15–16, 32).
- The common parlance test must be applied on objective material of trade understanding, not on licences or nomenclature (paras 19.1–20, 22).
- The Revenue bears the burden of proving classification under the residuary entry, and failed to discharge it (paras 21–22).
- The essential character of Rooh Afza comes from its fruit juice and distillates, not the quantitatively dominant sugar syrup (paras 24–25).
- Inclusive Entry 103 has no minimum fruit-content threshold, and "fruit drink" extends to sharbat preparations meant for dilution (paras 27–29).
- Uniform concessional treatment in other States shows two plausible views; the one favouring the assessee prevails (paras 33–37).
Brief Facts of the Case
The appellant manufactures "Sharbat Rooh Afza", a non-alcoholic sweetened beverage of invert sugar syrup blended with fruit juices, vegetable extracts and flavours. Its label declares 80% invert sugar syrup, 8% pineapple juice and 2% orange juice, with herbal distillates (paras 4, 13).
For 01.01.2008 to 31.03.2012, the appellant paid VAT at 4% treating the product as a "fruit drink" under Entry 103. The Assessing Authority held it to be an unclassified item taxable at 12.5% under the residuary entry in Schedule V. First appeals, second appeals before the Tribunal and revisions before the Allahabad High Court failed; the appellant paid Rs. 2,65,94,892 under protest (paras 3–4.1, 9).
The authorities relied on the appellant's licence to manufacture "Non-Fruit Syrup / Sharbat" and on an FSSAI clarification dated 31.07.2009 that a "fruit syrup" must contain at least 25% fruit juice, so the product was a "non-fruit syrup containing 10% fruit juice" (paras 6.1, 12–14).
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Whether "Sharbat Rooh Afza" is taxable at 4% as a "fruit drink" under Entry 103 of Part A of Schedule II, or at 12.5% under the residuary entry in Schedule V of the UPVAT Act (para 8).
- Whether regulatory classification under food law determines the meaning of the fiscal entry (paras 15–16).
- Whether the Revenue discharged its burden of proving residuary classification (paras 21–22).
Court's Findings and Reasoning
Regulatory classification not decisive (paras 15–16): Food-law instruments deal with quality control, safety and licensing. They are neither determinative nor conclusive for fiscal classification unless the taxing statute expressly adopts their definitions.
Common parlance test (paras 17–20): Relying on Ramavatar Budhaiprasad, Indo International Industries, A. Nagaraju Bros, Connaught Plaza Restaurant and Wockhardt Life Sciences, the Court held that classification depends on how the product is understood in trade, judged on its composition, literature, label, character and use. The dealer testimonials and market material filed by the appellant were not adequately considered.
Burden on Revenue (paras 21–22): Following Hindustan Ferodo, HPL Chemicals and Quinn India, the Court held that the Revenue must prove classification under the entry it invokes, especially the residuary entry. It produced no trade enquiry, consumer survey or market evidence, relying only on licensing norms and the word "sharbat".
Essential character (paras 23–26): Applying Rule 3(b) as explained in Kemrock Industries, the invert sugar syrup serves as carrier, sweetening medium and preservative base, while flavour, aroma and beverage character come from the fruit juice and distillates. The tariff definition of "sharbat" in Chapter 21 also recognises it as a flavoured beverage concentrate, not a generic sugar solution.
Inclusive entry and residuary entry (paras 27–32): Relying on RBI v. Peerless General Finance, the Court held that inclusive Entry 103 cannot be read narrowly or subjected to an unstated percentage requirement. Following Dunlop India and Alladi Venkateswarlu, a product with a reasonable claim to a specific entry cannot be consigned to the residuary clause because of its "sharbat" label or "non-fruit syrup" licence.
Treatment in other States (paras 33–37): VAT is a State subject and other States' classifications are not binding, but uniform concessional treatment under similarly worded entries has evidentiary value on commercial understanding. At the very least, two plausible views exist, and the one favouring the assessee must prevail.
Interference with concurrent findings (para 39): The findings below were reached by an erroneous application of settled classification principles and were vitiated by misdirection in law, so they were not insulated from appellate interference.
Final Outcome and Directions
- "Sharbat Rooh Afza" held classifiable under Entry 103 of Schedule II, Part A of the UPVAT Act as a fruit drink / processed fruit product, exigible to VAT at 4% for the relevant assessment years (para 40).
- Impugned judgments affirming classification under the residuary entry and levy at 12.5% set aside (para 40).
- Respondent authorities to grant consequential relief, including refund or adjustment of excess tax paid, in accordance with law; no costs (para 41).
Legal Principle Laid Down
An undefined entry in a taxing statute is construed by its own language and by commercial understanding proved by objective material, not by licensing or food-regulation categories. The Revenue bears the burden of proving that goods fall in a residuary entry. Composite goods are classified by the component that gives them their essential character, and an inclusive specific entry cannot be narrowed by reading in thresholds the legislature did not provide. Where two plausible views exist, the one favouring the assessee prevails (paras 16, 21.4, 25, 27, 30, 37).
Precedents Relied Upon
- Ramavatar Budhaiprasad v. Assistant Sales Tax Officer, (1961) 12 STC 286 – Relied upon – common parlance meaning of undefined fiscal terms. Discussed at para 17.
- A. Nagaraju Bros v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 1994 Supp (3) SCC 122 – Relied upon – commercial usage test preferred. Discussed at para 17.
- CCE v. Connaught Plaza Restaurant (P) Ltd., (2012) 13 SCC 639 – Relied upon – marketing nomenclature not decisive; consumer perception governs. Discussed at para 18.
- CCE v. Wockhardt Life Sciences Ltd., (2012) 5 SCC 585 – Relied upon – factors for the common parlance test. Discussed at paras 19–19.1.
- Hindustan Ferodo Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise, (1997) 2 SCC 677; HPL Chemicals Ltd. v. CCE, (2006) 5 SCC 208; Quinn India Ltd. v. CCE, (2006) 9 SCC 559 – Relied upon – burden of classification on Revenue. Discussed at paras 21.1–21.3.
- Kemrock Industries and Exports Ltd. v. CCE, 2007 (210) ELT 497 (SC) – Relied upon – essential character test. Discussed at para 24.
- Reserve Bank of India v. Peerless General Finance & Investment Co. Ltd., (1987) 1 SCC 424 – Relied upon – scope of inclusive definitions. Discussed at para 28.
- Dunlop India Ltd. v. Union of India, (1976) 2 SCC 241 – Relied upon – no resort to the residuary clause where a specific entry reasonably applies. Discussed at para 30.
- Alladi Venkateswarlu v. State of Andhra Pradesh, (1978) 2 SCC 552 – Relied upon – interpretation favouring the assessee where two views are possible. Discussed at para 31.
Important Paragraphs of the Judgment
Verbatim extracts from the judgment. For the full text, refer to the judgment PDF below.
Para 16: "It is trite that a fiscal statute must be interpreted in its own language."
Para 22: "Accordingly, it must be held that the Revenue has failed to discharge the burden cast upon it in law."
Para 25: "Classification must follow the component that confers upon the product its essential beverage character."
Para 27: "The Entry does not prescribe any minimum threshold of fruit content."
Para 32: "It cannot be relegated to the residuary entry merely because it is marketed as a “sharbat”."
Para 37: "At the very least, the existence of two plausible views stands demonstrated. In such a situation, the interpretation favourable to the assessee must prevail."
Practical Impact of the Ruling
- For assessees: Food-law labels and licence categories are not conclusive in tax classification; market evidence such as dealer testimonials should be placed on record (paras 16, 20).
- For tax authorities: Invoking a residuary entry needs cogent trade or market evidence; nomenclature and licensing norms alone will not do (paras 21.4–22).
- For classification disputes: Quantitative predominance of a base ingredient does not decide classification if it only carries or preserves the product (para 25).
- For beverage manufacturers: Inclusive "fruit drink" entries are not to be narrowed by minimum fruit-content thresholds that the statute does not provide (para 27).
FAQs on VAT Classification of Rooh Afza
1. What did the Supreme Court decide in Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories v. Commissioner, Commercial Tax?
It held that "Sharbat Rooh Afza" is a fruit drink under Entry 103 of the UPVAT Act taxable at 4%, not an unclassified item at 12.5% (para 40).
2. Does a "non-fruit syrup" licence under the Fruit Products Order decide tax classification?
No. Regulatory categories under food law are not determinative for fiscal classification unless the taxing statute adopts them (paras 16, 32).
3. Who must prove that a product falls in the residuary entry?
The Revenue. It must produce cogent material on commercial understanding, which it failed to do here (paras 21–22).
4. Why did the 80% sugar syrup content not decide the issue?
Under the essential character test, the sugar syrup is only a carrier and preservative; the fruit juice and distillates give the product its beverage identity (paras 24–25).
5. What relief did the appellant get?
The respondent authorities were directed to grant consequential relief, including refund or adjustment of excess tax paid, in accordance with law (para 41).
Keywords: 2026 INSC 195, Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories v. Commissioner Commercial Tax, Rooh Afza, Sharbat Rooh Afza VAT, UPVAT Act Entry 103, fruit drink classification, residuary entry Schedule V, Fruit Products Order, common parlance test, essential character test, burden of proof on Revenue, inclusive entry, interpretation favouring assessee, Justice R. Mahadevan, Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Supreme Court judgment
Related on LegalTaxGuru
Download Judgment PDF – Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories v. Commissioner, Commercial Tax
Source: Supreme Court of India (official website).