Quick Answer: Section 83 of the Waqf Act, 1995 only enables the State to constitute Waqf Tribunals; it does not by itself confer jurisdiction. A Tribunal can decide whether a property is a waqf only if the property is in the ‘list of auqaf’ (a survey list under Section 5(2) or the register under Section 37). The Supreme Court rejected a plaint seeking an injunction simpliciter before the Tribunal for an alleged mosque in a residential complex that was neither listed nor registered, leaving the waqf question open to be agitated in accordance with law.
In Habib Alladin & Ors. v. Mohammed Ahmed (2026 INSC 90), the Supreme Court affirmed the principle in Ramesh Gobindram v. Sugra Humayun Mirza Wakf that the Waqf Tribunal's jurisdiction, and the ouster of the Civil Court under Section 85, extend only to matters specifically conferred on the Tribunal by and under the Act (paras 44, 47, 49). It disagreed with the expansive reading of Section 83 in W.B. Wakf Board v. Anis Fatma Begum and in paragraphs 54.17 to 54.19 of Rashid Wali Beg v. Farid Pindari (paras 28–29, 39–40, 46–47), and held that the 2013 substitution of the definition of ‘list of auqaf’ is clarificatory and applies from the inception of the Act (para 35). A Bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice K. Vinod Chandran allowed the defendants' appeal and rejected the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC (paras 50–51).
Status: Order of the Waqf Tribunal rejecting the Order VII Rule 11 application, and the High Court's order affirming it in revision, set aside; plaint rejected; question whether the scheduled property is a waqf left open; Civil Appeal allowed (paras 50–51).
Headnote: Jurisdiction of the Waqf Tribunal and Section 83 of the Waqf Act
Waqf Act, 1995 – Sections 3(g), 3(r), 5, 6, 7, 37, 54, 83 and 85 – Waqf (Amendment) Act 27 of 2013 – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Order VII Rule 11 – Jurisdiction of Waqf Tribunal – Ouster of Civil Court jurisdiction – ‘List of auqaf’ – Injunction simpliciter for alleged mosque – Waqf by user – Substitution by amendment – Clarificatory and retrospective – Divergent coordinate bench decisions.
Held: (i) The larger principle in Ramesh Gobindram, that the ouster of Civil Court jurisdiction is confined to the precise power conferred under the statute, survives the 2013 amendment; the Tribunal decides whether a property is a waqf under Sections 6 and 7 only for properties in the ‘list of auqaf’ defined in Section 3(g) (paras 12, 15–16, 44).
(ii) Anis Fatma Begum was in clear conflict with Ramesh Gobindram on Section 83; a coordinate bench taking a divergent view ought to have referred the matter to a Larger Bench, and the facts there did not require such a finding (paras 28–29, 36).
(iii) The 2013 amendment expanding the definition of ‘list of auqaf’ to include the register under Section 37 is procedural, and the substitution is clarificatory and applies to the Act from its inception (paras 32–33, 35).
(iv) Section 83 merely enables the constitution of Tribunals; the words ‘under this Act’ require the waqf or waqf property to have a status under the Act, possible only by inclusion in the ‘list of auqaf’; the power to remove encroachers flows from Section 54(3) and (4), not Section 83(1) (paras 37, 44, 46–48).
(v) The Court concurred with paragraphs 54.1 to 54.16 and 54.20 of Rashid Wali Beg but held the expansion of jurisdiction in paragraphs 54.17 to 54.19 based on Section 83 to be contrary to Ramesh Gobindram; Kiran Devi and Mumtaz Yarud Dowla Wakf turned on their own facts and did not overrule Ramesh Gobindram (paras 39–43).
(vi) There is no absolute and all-pervasive ouster of Civil Court jurisdiction even under Section 85; since the suit property was neither in a Chapter II list nor registered under Chapter V, the injunction simpliciter sought before the Tribunal was outside its jurisdiction and the plaint was rejected (paras 47, 50).
(paras 12–51)
Case Details: Habib Alladin v. Mohammed Ahmed (2026 INSC 90)
Final Outcome: Civil Appeal allowed; Order VII Rule 11 application of the defendants allowed and plaint rejected; orders of the Tribunal and the High Court set aside; whether the scheduled property is a waqf left open to be agitated in accordance with law.
Case: Habib Alladin & Ors. v. Mohammed Ahmed
Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 90
Case No.: Civil Appeal No. ___ of 2026 (arising out of SLP (C) No. 2937 of 2022)
Court: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction) – Reportable
Date of Decision: 28 January 2026
Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice K. Vinod Chandran (author)
Relevant Acts & Sections: Waqf Act, 1995 – Sections 2, 3(g), 3(r), 4, 5, 6, 7, 37, 54, 83 and 85; Waqf (Amendment) Act 27 of 2013; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Order VII Rule 11
Impugned Order: Order of the High Court dismissing the defendants' revision against the Tribunal's rejection of their Order VII Rule 11 application; the High Court found the plaint averments to indicate a ‘waqf by user’ under Section 3(r)(i) (para 4)
Counsel: Shri C. Aryama Sundaram, Senior Counsel, for the appellants; Shri Niranjan Reddy, Senior Counsel, for the respondent-plaintiff (paras 5, 7)
Source: Supreme Court of India
Key Holdings of the Supreme Court
- The principle of jurisdiction of the Tribunal and of ouster of the Civil Court under Section 85, as declared in Ramesh Gobindram, is affirmed; the 2013 amendment removes its sub-stratum only on the removal of encroachers (para 49).
- The Tribunal can decide whether a property is a waqf under Sections 6(1) and 7(1) only if the property is specified in the ‘list of auqaf’, which includes the Section 5(2) list and the Section 37 register (paras 12, 44, 50).
- Section 83 does not confer any jurisdiction on the Tribunal; it merely enables its constitution (paras 44, 47).
- The 2013 substitution of Section 3(g) is clarificatory and applies from the inception of the Act (para 35).
- The expansive reading of Section 83 in Anis Fatma Begum and in paragraphs 54.17 to 54.19 of Rashid Wali Beg is not accepted (paras 28–29, 40, 46).
- An injunction simpliciter for an unlisted, unregistered property does not fall within the Tribunal's jurisdiction (para 50).
Brief Facts of the Case
The first appellant owned land on which an apartment complex was built by a builder under a development agreement. The respondent claimed that an area on the ground floor, meant for residential purpose, had been enclosed as a Mosque with the owner's participation, that he and other members of the public had offered prayers there since 2008, and that ingress was obstructed in 2021. He sued before the Waqf Tribunal for a perpetual injunction restraining interference with the plaintiff and other Musallies entering the premises and offering prayers (para 3).
The appellants applied under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, contending that no Mosque existed, none was shown in the sanctioned plan, and the property was not a waqf under the Act since it was neither in the notified list nor registered by the Board. The application was rejected, and the High Court dismissed the revision, finding that the plaint averments indicated a ‘waqf by user’ under Section 3(r)(i) (para 4).
Before the Supreme Court, the appellants argued that a declaration of waqf status for an unlisted property had to be sought before the Civil Court and that Rashid Wali Beg required reconsideration in view of Ramesh Gobindram. The respondent argued that Section 83 is a third route for determining waqf status and that Rashid Wali Beg correctly states the law (paras 5–9).
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- What is the reach of the Waqf Tribunal's jurisdiction, in view of divergent opinions of coordinate benches on Section 83 (paras 2, 10–11)?
- Whether the 2013 amendment removed the basis of Ramesh Gobindram, and whether the substituted definition of ‘list of auqaf’ is retrospective (paras 12, 30–36, 39).
- Whether Section 83 independently confers jurisdiction on the Tribunal over any dispute relating to a waqf or waqf property (paras 37, 44–48).
- Whether the plaint seeking an injunction simpliciter for an unlisted property was liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 (para 50).
Court's Findings and Reasoning
Ramesh Gobindram survives (paras 12–16): The 2013 amendment offset only the holding that the Tribunal could not evict tenants. The principle that the Tribunal decides waqf status under Sections 6 and 7 only for properties in the ‘list of auqaf’, and the interpretation of Sections 83 and 85, survive; Section 85 is substantially the same after the amendment.
Two lines of decisions (paras 17–27): The Court traced the decisions following Ramesh Gobindram (Bhanwar Lal, Mahesh Kumar, Sham Singh Harike, Faseela M.) and those distinguishing it (Anis Fatma Begum, Pritpal Singh, P.V. Ibrahim Haji, Mohamed Muzafar, Kiran Devi). Pritpal Singh, a short order not dealing with the provisions, was held to lack the sheen of a binding precedent (para 24).
Anis Fatma Begum in conflict (paras 28–29, 36): Its wider reading of Section 83(1) ignored the words ‘under this Act’ and was opposite to Ramesh Gobindram; following Pranay Sethi, the coordinate bench ought to have referred the matter to a Larger Bench. On its facts, the property was a registered waqf estate and the dispute fell squarely under Section 6(1) or 7(1).
2013 amendment clarificatory (paras 30–35): Even before 2013 a waqf could be recognised by a survey list under Section 5(2) or by registration under Section 37. Relying on Hitendra Vishnu Thakur and Zile Singh, the Court held the expanded definition procedural and the substitution clarificatory, applying from inception. Because of this amendment, the Court did not make the reference it would otherwise have been persuaded to make (para 36).
Rashid Wali Beg not accepted on Section 83 (paras 39–43): The Court concurred with paragraphs 54.1 to 54.16 and 54.20 but not with 54.17 to 54.19. Kiran Devi turned on the bar against approbate and reprobate, and Mumtaz Yarud Dowla Wakf could have been decided on that dictum; neither overruled Ramesh Gobindram.
Section 83 is only enabling (paras 44–48): Pritpal Singh and Rashid Wali Beg omitted the words ‘under this Act’ in Section 83(1). The words added in 2013 on eviction of tenants are an abundant clarification; the power to remove encroachers lies in Section 54(3) and (4), invocable only by the Chief Executive Officer, which would be pointless if Section 83 already conferred it.
Application to the plaint (para 50): The property was neither in a list published under Chapter II nor registered under Chapter V, so its waqf status could not be decided by the Tribunal. The Court did not consider whether it could be a ‘waqf by user’, as that question is still at large.
Final Outcome and Directions
- Order VII Rule 11 application of the defendants allowed and the plaint rejected (para 50).
- Order of the Tribunal ascertaining jurisdiction and the High Court's order affirming it set aside (para 50).
- Appeal allowed, rejecting the suit filed before the Tribunal (para 51).
- Question whether the scheduled property is a waqf left open to be agitated in accordance with law (para 51).
- Pending applications disposed of (para 52).
Legal Principle Laid Down
Section 83 of the Waqf Act, 1995 only enables the constitution of Waqf Tribunals and does not by itself confer jurisdiction. The Tribunal's jurisdiction, and the ouster of the Civil Court under Section 85, extend only to matters required by or under the Act to be determined by the Tribunal. A dispute whether a property is a waqf lies before the Tribunal under Sections 6(1) and 7(1) only when the property is in the ‘list of auqaf’, that is, a list published under Section 5(2) or the register under Section 37; the 2013 substitution of that definition is clarificatory and applies from the inception of the Act (paras 35, 44, 46–47, 49–50).
Precedents Relied Upon
- Ramesh Gobindram v. Sugra Humayun Mirza Wakf, (2010) 8 SCC 726 – Followed and affirmed – Tribunal's jurisdiction and Civil Court ouster confined to powers specifically conferred. Discussed at paras 10–16, 44, 49.
- W.B. Wakf Board v. Anis Fatma Begum, (2010) 14 SCC 588 – Held in conflict with Ramesh Gobindram – wider interpretation of Section 83 not warranted. Discussed at paras 23, 28–29, 35–36.
- Rashid Wali Beg v. Farid Pindari, (2022) 4 SCC 414 – Not followed in part – paragraphs 54.17 to 54.19 held contrary to Ramesh Gobindram. Discussed at paras 39–41, 45–46.
- Kiran Devi v. Bihar State Sunni Wakf Board, (2021) 15 SCC 15 – Explained – turned on approbate and reprobate. Discussed at paras 27, 42.
- National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 – Applied – a coordinate bench taking a divergent view should refer to a Larger Bench. Discussed at paras 11, 28.
- Zile Singh v. State of Haryana, (2004) 8 SCC 1 – Relied upon – substitution to remove an anomaly may operate retrospectively. Discussed at paras 33–36.
- Hitendra Vishnu Thakur v. State of Maharashtra, (1994) 4 SCC 602 – Relied upon – law relating to forum is procedural. Discussed at paras 31–32.
Important Paragraphs of the Judgment
Verbatim extracts from the judgment. For the full text, refer to the judgment PDF below.
Para 12: "However, the larger principle of the ouster of jurisdiction of civil courts being confined to the precise power conferred under the statute, according to us, survives the amendment and is not extinguished by reason of the particular amendment."
Para 32: "The right of action remained as such but the forum in which the issue had to be agitated was specified to be the Tribunal under the Act of 1995."
Para 35: "The legislative measure of substitution having been employed in the amendment of Section 3(g) we are of the opinion that it was clarificatory in nature and applies to the Act from its inception."
Para 46: "The wakf or wakf properties should thus be having a status under the Act which is possible only by inclusion in the ‘list of auqaf’ which as of now includes a list published after a survey under Chapter II or a registration made under Chapter V."
Para 47: "There is hence no absolute and all-pervasive ouster of jurisdiction of the Civil Court even under Section 85 of the Act of 1995."
Para 50: "The injunction simpliciter sought for before the Tribunal does not fall within its jurisdiction and the plaint has to be rejected, which we do, allowing the application of the defendant under Order VII, Rule 11."
Practical Impact of the Ruling
- For litigants claiming waqf status: Where a property is neither in the survey list nor registered with the Board, a suit before the Waqf Tribunal for injunction or declaration of waqf status is liable to be rejected; the question remains open in the appropriate forum (paras 50–51).
- For property owners and defendants: Order VII Rule 11 is available to challenge a Tribunal suit concerning an unlisted, unregistered property (para 50).
- For Waqf Boards: Removal of encroachers before the Tribunal must be pursued through the Chief Executive Officer under Section 54(3) and (4), not directly under Section 83 (paras 46, 48).
- For Tribunals and Civil Courts: Jurisdiction must be traced to a specific provision of the Act; Section 85 does not create an all-pervasive bar (paras 47, 49).
FAQs on Waqf Tribunal Jurisdiction
1. What did the Supreme Court decide in Habib Alladin v. Mohammed Ahmed?
It allowed the defendants' Order VII Rule 11 application and rejected a plaint filed before the Waqf Tribunal for an injunction concerning an alleged mosque in a residential complex, leaving the waqf question open (paras 50–51).
2. Does Section 83 of the Waqf Act give the Tribunal jurisdiction over every waqf dispute?
No. Section 83 merely enables the constitution of Tribunals; jurisdiction comes from the specific provisions of the Act (paras 44, 47).
3. When can the Tribunal decide whether a property is a waqf?
Only when the property is specified in the ‘list of auqaf’, which includes a list published under Section 5(2) and the register maintained under Section 37 (paras 44, 46, 50).
4. Is the 2013 amendment to the definition of ‘list of auqaf’ retrospective?
Yes. The Court held the substitution clarificatory, applying to the Act from its inception (para 35).
5. Did the Court decide whether the premises were a ‘waqf by user’?
No. It expressly did not consider that question, which is left open to be agitated in accordance with law (paras 50–51).
Keywords: 2026 INSC 90, Habib Alladin v. Mohammed Ahmed, Waqf Act 1995, Waqf Tribunal jurisdiction, Section 83 Waqf Act, Section 85 Waqf Act, list of auqaf, Section 6 and 7 Waqf Act, Section 37 register, waqf by user, Order VII Rule 11 CPC, Ramesh Gobindram, Rashid Wali Beg, Anis Fatma Begum, Waqf Amendment Act 2013, Justice K. Vinod Chandran, Justice Sanjay Kumar, Supreme Court judgment
Related on LegalTaxGuru
Download Judgment PDF – Habib Alladin v. Mohammed Ahmed
Judgment PDF: 2026 INSC 90 – Habib Alladin & Ors. v. Mohammed Ahmed (Civil Appeal No. ___ of 2026) – Download Judgment PDF
Source: Supreme Court of India (official website).