Quick Answer: Cutting imported aluminium composite panels (ACPs) to size and grooving or routing them for fixing on building façades is not "manufacture" under Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act, 1944, because what emerges is still an ACP. The Supreme Court also held that a dispute on excisability relates to the "rate of duty", so an appeal against a CESTAT order on it lies only to the Supreme Court under Section 35L, not to the High Court under Section 35G.
In M/s Alupro Building Systems Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Bangalore-II (2026 INSC 582), the Supreme Court held that the excisability of goods is intrinsically connected with the rate of duty for the purpose of assessment, so the Revenue's appeal against the CESTAT order ought to have been filed in the Supreme Court under Section 35L(1)(b) and not in the High Court under Section 35G (paras 26, 36–38). Sub-section (2) of Section 35L, inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2014, is clarificatory and retrospective (paras 43–47, 53). On merits, cutting, grooving and routing of ACPs does not bring into existence a distinct product, and the burden of proving marketability lies on the Revenue (paras 65–67, 76, 86, 96, 98). A Bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice R. Mahadevan allowed the assessee's appeal (para 99).
Status: Karnataka High Court judgment dated 01.04.2010 in Central Excise Appeal No. 17/2007 set aside; Civil Appeal allowed (paras 1, 99).
Headnote: Cutting and Grooving of ACPs Not Manufacture
Central Excise Act, 1944 – Sections 2(f), 35G and 35L(1)(b), 35L(2) – Finance (No. 2) Act, 2014 – Appeal against CESTAT order – Excisability as question relating to "rate of duty" – Jurisdiction of High Court – Clarificatory amendment – Retrospective effect – Manufacture – Aluminium composite panels – Cutting, grooving and routing – Transformation test – Marketability – Burden and standard of proof on Revenue.
Held: (i) The bracketed exclusion in Section 35G(1) is a negative condition; the word "any" and the phrase "among other things" give it a wide sweep, but the question must relate to rate of duty or value specifically for purposes of assessment (paras 22, 24–25).
(ii) Excisability is not distinct from "rate of duty"; the two are sequentially and logically interdependent, and a decision on excisability is a precursor to determining the rate of duty for assessment. A question on excisability also has consequences in rem for all assessees dealing in the goods (paras 26–27).
(iii) Jurisdiction under Section 35G cannot be assumed merely because the question is framed as a question of law; what Section 35G excludes, Section 35L picks up. The Revenue ought to have appealed to the Supreme Court, and the High Court left the assessee's maintainability objection unaddressed (paras 30, 34, 36–38).
(iv) Section 35L(2) does not create a new right of appeal or a new jurisdiction; it makes explicit what was always implicit in Sections 35G and 35L and is clarificatory and retrospective (paras 43, 45–47, 53).
(v) Cutting, grooving and bending of ACPs merely adapts their size and shape for use as cladding; their essential character remains unchanged, and fixing them on frames at site is installation. No distinct goods emerge (paras 65–67, 72–73, 76).
(vi) Both limbs of the two-fold test (transformation and marketability) must be satisfied conjunctively. The burden of proving marketability lies on the Revenue, on objective evidence, and the degree of probability required depends on the goods in question (paras 79, 85–86, 93–95, 97).
(paras 17–99)
Case Details: Alupro Building Systems v. CCE, Bangalore-II (2026 INSC 582)
Final Outcome: Civil Appeal allowed; impugned judgment of the Karnataka High Court set aside.
Case: M/s Alupro Building Systems Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Bangalore-II
Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 582
Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 8030 of 2010
Court: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction) – Reportable
Date of Decision: 27 May 2026
Bench: Justice J.B. Pardiwala (author) and Justice R. Mahadevan
Relevant Acts & Sections: Central Excise Act, 1944 – Sections 2(f), 35G, 35L(1)(b) and 35L(2); Finance (No. 2) Act, 2014; Customs Act, 1962 – Sections 130 and 130E (pari materia)
Impugned Order: Judgment and order dated 01.04.2010 of the High Court of Karnataka in Central Excise Appeal No. 17/2007, which set aside CESTAT Final Order No. 1112/2006 dated 27.06.2006 and restored the Commissioner (Appeals) order dated 28.10.2005 (paras 1, 11, 13)
Counsel: Ms. Charanya Lakshmikumaran for the appellant-assessee; Mr. N. Venkataraman, Additional Solicitor General, with Mr. G.S. Makker, assisted by V. Chandrashekara Bharathi, for the respondent-Revenue (paras 15–16)
Source: Supreme Court of India
Key Holdings of the Supreme Court
- An appeal against a CESTAT order determining excisability of goods lies to the Supreme Court under Section 35L(1)(b), not to the High Court under Section 35G (paras 26, 36–38, 97).
- The exclusion in Section 35G is not attracted by every question touching rate or value; the question must have a direct and proximate relationship with assessment (paras 25, 97).
- Section 35L(2), inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2014, is clarificatory and operates retrospectively (paras 41–47, 53, 97).
- Cutting, grooving and routing of imported ACPs, followed by fixing them on frames at site, does not amount to manufacture under Section 2(f) (paras 65–67, 76, 98).
- The place where the process is carried out, or the fact that the customer gave the specifications, does not make it manufacture (para 74).
- Marketability must be proved by the Revenue on objective evidence; past payment of duty by the assessee is not evidence of marketability (paras 86–87, 95).
Brief Facts of the Case
The appellant, a construction contractor, imported pre-coated ACPs (an aluminium sheet bonded to each side of a polyethylene core) in standard sizes, paying customs duty. At its premises it cut them into panels of the required size and made grooves on the back (routing/grooving); the panels were then fixed on frames erected at the building with angles, clamps and fasteners, and the gaps sealed (paras 2–4).
The appellant paid excise duty on this activity until April 2002 and then stopped, believing it was not manufacture. A show cause notice dated 14.09.2004 demanded duty of Rs. 21,46,437 for clearances from April 2002 to December 2003, with interest and penalty. The appellant had already paid the duty and interest (paras 5–7).
The Additional Commissioner confirmed the demand on 21.06.2005. The Commissioner (Appeals), on 28.10.2005, set aside the penalty and interest but held the activity to be manufacture. The CESTAT, on 27.06.2006, allowed the assessee's appeal, holding that no new product emerged and that the Revenue had not proved marketability. The High Court allowed the Revenue's appeal under Section 35G on 01.04.2010, holding that a new commercially identifiable product emerged (paras 8–13).
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Whether the High Court had jurisdiction to decide the issue on excisability of the aluminium composite panels (para 17).
- Whether cutting and grooving or routing of the panels as per desired measurements amounts to "manufacture" under Section 2(f) of the Act, 1944 (para 17).
Court's Findings and Reasoning
Structure of Section 35G (paras 19–25): The Court broke Section 35G into two positive conditions (order on or after 01.07.2003; substantial question of law) and one negative condition (the order must not relate to rate of duty or value for purposes of assessment). If the negative condition is attracted, the appeal does not lie regardless of the others. "For purposes of assessment" governs both limbs.
Excisability is a rate-of-duty question (paras 26–28): The argument that excisability is distinct from rate of duty was rejected at the threshold. Excisability is a precursor to the rate of duty, its consequences apply to all assessees dealing in the goods, and the High Court's statutory jurisdiction must be strictly construed.
Question of law does not confer jurisdiction (paras 29–38): Referring to Ernst and Young (Delhi HC), the Full Bench in Reliance Media Works (Bombay HC), Motorola and Navin Chemicals, and Munshi Ram on statutory forums, the Court held that Sections 35G and 35L form a complete and mutually exclusive appellate scheme. The only determination by the CESTAT was excisability, so the Revenue should have approached the Supreme Court.
Section 35L(2) clarificatory (paras 39–53): Relying on the Notes on Clauses to the Finance (No. 2) Bill, 2014, the phrase "shall include", Podar Cement, M. Rajendran, Merlin J.N., Reliance Media Works and DLF Golf Resorts, the Court held that the sub-section creates no new right, jurisdiction or obligation and only makes explicit what was implicit, so it operates retrospectively.
Two-fold test of manufacture (paras 57–64): The taxable event is manufacture. Following Delhi Cloth & General Mills, J.G. Glass, Servo-Med and Quippo, both transformation and marketability must be satisfied, and the "but for" test is not sufficient by itself.
No distinct goods emerge (paras 65–76): What enters the process is an ACP and what emerges is still an ACP, cut, grooved and bent. Applying Bharat Forge, S.R. Tissues, Aman Marble and Bheraghat Mineral Industries, the Court held the process merely adapts the goods for a particular use; the site work is installation, and the location of the process is not significant.
Marketability and burden of proof (paras 77–96): Marketability means goods capable of being bought and sold as distinct articles known in the market (Moti Laminates, Sonic Electrochem). The Revenue must prove it on objective evidence (Union Carbide, Ambalal Sarabhai, United Phosphorus, Hindustan Zinc, Gujarat Narmada Valley, Cipla) on a preponderance of probabilities calibrated to the goods (Bater v. Bater). As no transformation occurred here, marketability did not need to be decided.
Final Outcome and Directions
- The process undertaken by the appellant does not result in a distinct product (para 98).
- Civil Appeal allowed and the impugned judgment of the Karnataka High Court set aside (para 99).
- Pending applications, if any, disposed of (para 99).
Legal Principle Laid Down
A question of excisability of goods relates to the rate of duty for the purpose of assessment; an appeal against a CESTAT order deciding it lies only to the Supreme Court under Section 35L(1)(b), and Section 35L(2) merely clarifies this with retrospective effect. Superficial processes that facilitate the use of goods without altering their fundamental properties do not pass the transformation test, and the Revenue must prove marketability of the resultant goods on evidence (para 97).
Precedents Relied Upon
- Navin Chemicals Manufacturing & Trading Co. Ltd. v. Collector of Customs, (1993) 4 SCC 320 – Relied upon – questions relating directly and proximately to rate of duty or value for assessment. Discussed at paras 15, 32–33.
- CCE v. Reliance Media Works Ltd., 2019 SCC OnLine Bom 5162 (Full Bench) – Approved – excisability is part of assessment; Section 35L(2) clarificatory and retrospective. Discussed at paras 32, 51.
- Commr. of Customs v. Motorola (India) Ltd., (2019) 9 SCC 563 – Relied upon – appeals on rate of duty or value lie to the Supreme Court under the pari materia Customs provisions. Discussed at para 33.
- University of Kerala v. Merlin J.N., (2022) 9 SCC 389 – Relied upon – clarificatory amendments operate retrospectively. Discussed at para 50.
- M. Rajendran v. KPK Oils & Protiens India (P) Ltd., (2026) 3 SCC 505 – Relied upon – presumption against retrospectivity inapplicable to procedural, forum and declaratory enactments. Discussed at para 49.
- Union of India v. Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd., 1962 SCC OnLine SC 148 – Relied upon – manufacture means bringing into existence a new substance. Discussed at paras 63, 75.
- Servo-Med Industries (P) Ltd. v. CCE, (2015) 14 SCC 47 and Quippo Energy Ltd. v. CCE, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2021 – Explained – transformation and marketability tests. Discussed at paras 61–63, 75.
- Bharat Forge and Press Industries (P) Ltd. v. CCE, (1990) 1 SCC 532 – Relied upon – pipe fittings remain pipes and tubes. Discussed at para 68.
- CCE v. S.R. Tissues (P) Ltd., (2005) 6 SCC 310 and Aman Marble Industries (P) Ltd. v. CCE, (2005) 1 SCC 279 – Relied upon – cutting to size is not manufacture. Discussed at paras 69–70.
- Moti Laminates (P) Ltd. v. CCE, (1995) 3 SCC 23 and Union of India v. Sonic Electrochem (P) Ltd., (2002) 7 SCC 435 – Relied upon – meaning of marketability. Discussed at paras 82–83.
- Union Carbide India Ltd. v. Union of India, (1986) 2 SCC 547 – Relied upon – past payment of duty is not evidence of marketability. Discussed at para 87.
Important Paragraphs of the Judgment
Verbatim extracts from the judgment. For the full text, refer to the judgment PDF below.
Para 26: "The argument that the question of excisability is distinct from the question of “rate of duty” deserves to be rejected at the threshold. The two questions are not merely related, they are sequentially and logically interdependent."
Para 34: "What Section 35G excludes, Section 35L picks up. The exclusion in Section 35G is, therefore, meaningful only when read alongwith Section 35L."
Para 43: "It merely gives statutory expression to what was already the natural and necessary consequence of collective reading of Sections 35G and 35L, respectively. As a result, such a clarificatory amendment would have retrospective effect."
Para 65: "We say so because what enters the process is an ACP consisting of two aluminium sheets bonded to a polyethylene core, and what emerges from the process is still an ACP cut to a particular size, grooved at the edges, and bent into a frame."
Para 72: "The question is also not as to whether the goods look different after the process, but whether they could be regarded as different goods commercially. For instance, a piece of cloth cut into a various shape would still be a cloth."
Para 86: "It is well settled that the burden of establishing marketability lies on the Revenue."
Practical Impact of the Ruling
- For the Revenue and assessees: Appeals against CESTAT orders on excisability or taxability lie directly to the Supreme Court; a High Court appeal under Section 35G is the wrong forum, even for periods before 2014 (paras 38, 53).
- For contractors and fabricators: Cutting, grooving or routing duty-paid or imported materials to fit a project, and installing them, does not by itself attract excise duty as manufacture (paras 66–67, 73).
- For adjudicating authorities: A demand must rest on evidence of both transformation and marketability; the mere fact of a process, or past payment of duty, will not do (paras 85–87, 95).
- For High Courts: A maintainability objection under Section 35G must be addressed before the merits (para 36).
FAQs on Excisability and Manufacture of ACPs
1. What did the Supreme Court decide in Alupro Building Systems v. CCE?
It held that cutting and grooving ACPs is not manufacture and that the excisability appeal should have been filed in the Supreme Court, and it set aside the Karnataka High Court judgment (paras 38, 98–99).
2. Where does an appeal on excisability of goods lie against a CESTAT order?
Before the Supreme Court under Section 35L(1)(b), because excisability is a question relating to the rate of duty for purposes of assessment (paras 26, 37–38).
3. Is Section 35L(2) of the Central Excise Act retrospective?
Yes. It is clarificatory, creates no new right or jurisdiction, and only makes explicit what was implicit in Sections 35G and 35L (paras 43, 47, 53).
4. Why is cutting and routing of ACPs not manufacture?
The goods remain ACPs; the process only adapts their size and shape for use as cladding, and fixing them at site is installation (paras 65–67, 73).
5. Who must prove marketability, and how?
The Revenue, on objective evidence, on a preponderance of probabilities proportionate to the nature of the goods; a mere assertion is not enough (paras 86, 91, 93–95).
Keywords: 2026 INSC 582, Alupro Building Systems v. Commissioner of Central Excise, aluminium composite panels, ACP cutting and grooving, manufacture Section 2(f), Central Excise Act 1944, Section 35G, Section 35L, Section 35L(2) retrospective, excisability rate of duty, CESTAT appeal Supreme Court, transformation test, marketability, burden of proof on Revenue, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R. Mahadevan, Supreme Court judgment
Related on LegalTaxGuru
Download Judgment PDF – Alupro Building Systems v. CCE, Bangalore-II
Source: Supreme Court of India (official website).