Candidate Rejected for Squint Must Be Appointed After KGMU Board Finds Vision Normal, No Seniority: Supreme Court in Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P. [2026 INSC 1184]

Supreme Court directs appointment of a UP Police Constable candidate rejected for squint after a KGMU, Lucknow expert board found her vision normal. She cannot claim seniority over those already appointed.

Candidate Rejected for Squint Must Be Appointed After KGMU Board Finds Vision Normal, No Seniority: Supreme Court in Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P. [2026 INSC 1184]
Police constable candidate rejected for squint to be appointed – Supreme Court in Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P., 2026 INSC 1184

Quick Answer: A candidate who cleared every stage of UP Police Constable recruitment but was rejected by two departmental medical boards for a "squint eye" must be given her appointment letter, if otherwise entitled, after an expert board of King George's Medical University, Lucknow found her vision normal. She cannot, however, claim seniority over candidates already appointed.

In Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P. & Ors. (2026 INSC 1184), the Supreme Court set aside the High Court's order refusing a fresh medical examination to a candidate for the post of Constable Civil Police under the U.P. Police Constable Civil Direct Recruitment, 2023, who had been declared unfit on account of a squint (paras 2, 5). Relying on the report of a medical board of King George's Medical University (KGMU), Lucknow, which it had itself directed, a Bench of Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi held that she had been deprived of her legitimate right to appointment and directed the respondents to issue her appointment order or call letter if she is otherwise entitled, without seniority over those already appointed (paras 3–5).

Status: High Court's order dismissing the writ petition set aside; appeal allowed; appointment directed if otherwise entitled, without seniority over already appointed candidates (paras 5–6).

Headnote: Medical Rejection of Police Constable Candidate for Squint

Service Law – Police recruitment – U.P. Police Constable Civil Direct Recruitment, 2023 – Medical examination – Rejection for squint eye – UP Police Constable and Head Constable Service Rules, 2015 (as amended in 2017), Rule 15(6)(d) – Re-examination by Division Medical Board – Independent expert medical board constituted by the Supreme Court – Appointment directed – No seniority over appointed candidates – Article 136.

Held: (i) Where a candidate who cleared the Document Verification and Physical Standard Test was declared medically unfit for squint by the medical board and the Division Medical Board, but independent eye specialists found her vision normal, the Court could have her examined by an independent expert board, as it had done in a similar case (paras 2–3).

(ii) The report of the KGMU medical board of four doctors, recording best-corrected vision of 6/6 in each eye and other parameters within normal limits, persuaded the Court that the candidate had been deprived of her legitimate right to be appointed after clearing all tests (paras 4–5).

(iii) In the peculiar facts of the case, the High Court's dismissal of the writ petition on the ground that the selection process had concluded could not stand; the respondents were directed to issue the appointment order or call letter if she is otherwise entitled (paras 2, 5).

(iv) The appellant shall not claim seniority over candidates already appointed (para 5).

(paras 2–6)

Case Details: Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P. (2026 INSC 1184)

Final Outcome: Appeal allowed; impugned High Court order set aside; respondents directed to issue appointment order/call letter if the appellant is otherwise entitled; no seniority over already appointed candidates.

Case: Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P. & Ors.

Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1184

Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 14041 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 14082 of 2026)

Court: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction) – Non-Reportable

Date of Decision: 2 November 2026

Bench: Justice Aravind Kumar (author) and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi

Relevant Acts & Sections: UP Police Constable and Head Constable Service Rules, 2015 (as amended in 2017), Rule 15(6)(d); U.P. Police Constable Civil Direct Recruitment, 2023; Constitution of India, Article 136

Impugned Order: Order of the jurisdictional High Court dismissing the appellant's writ petition seeking re-conduct of the medical examination on the ground that the selection process had concluded (para 2)

Source: Supreme Court of India (official website)

Key Holdings of the Supreme Court

  • The appellant had cleared the Document Verification and Physical Standard Test and was included in the qualified list before being declared unfit for squint (para 2).
  • Following its approach in SLP (Civil) No. 17704/2025, the Court directed KGMU, Lucknow to constitute an expert ophthalmology board to examine her (para 3).
  • The KGMU board, after clinical examination by four doctors on 08.10.2026, recorded best-corrected vision of 6/6 in both eyes and normal findings on the other tests (para 4).
  • The report persuaded the Court that she had been deprived of her legitimate right to be appointed after clearing all tests (para 5).
  • Appointment order or call letter to be issued if she is otherwise entitled, without seniority over those already appointed (para 5).

Brief Facts of the Case

The appellant applied for the post of Constable Civil Police under the U.P. Police Constable Civil Direct Recruitment, 2023. She appeared for Document Verification and the Physical Standard Test at Reserves Police Line, Kanpur Dehat on 28.12.2024, cleared them and was included in the qualified list for the next phase (para 2).

At the medical examination on 22.04.2025 she was orally told she was unfit due to a squint. A re-examination by the Division Medical Board on 25.04.2025 under Rule 15(6)(d) of the UP Police Constable and Head Constable Service Rules, 2015 again declared her unfit, but no rejection order was furnished to her (para 2).

She obtained opinions from two eye specialists in Kanpur who found her vision and colour perception normal, and on 16.05.2025 sought a fresh examination before an independent authority. The representation was rejected, and the High Court dismissed her writ petition on the ground that the selection process had concluded (para 2).

By order dated 15.09.2026, the Supreme Court directed her to appear before KGMU, Lucknow and asked its Director to constitute a medical board of ophthalmology experts to report on her medical fitness, specifically regarding the squint (para 3).

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Whether the appellant, declared unfit for squint by the departmental boards, was medically fit for appointment as Constable Civil Police (paras 2–4).
  2. Whether the High Court was right in refusing relief on the ground that the selection process had concluded (paras 2, 5).

Court's Findings and Reasoning

Independent expert board (para 3): Noting that in similar circumstances it had constituted a medical board in SLP (Civil) No. 17704/2025, the Court directed KGMU, Lucknow to examine the appellant, since she had been denied employment after receiving a call letter because of the alleged eye defect.

KGMU report (para 4): The committee's report dated 16.10.2026 recorded that the appellant was examined on 08.10.2026 by a team of four doctors; best-corrected vision was 6/6 in each eye and most parameters were within normal limits, with an orthoptic clinic opinion on exophoria.

Right to appointment (para 5): In the peculiar facts of the case, and particularly in the teeth of the KGMU board certifying her vision as proper/normal, the Court accepted her plea of having been deprived of her legitimate right to be appointed after clearing all the tests, and set aside the impugned order.

Limited relief (para 5): The direction to issue an appointment order is conditional on her being otherwise entitled, and she cannot claim seniority over candidates already appointed.

Final Outcome and Directions

  • The impugned High Court order is set aside and the appeal is allowed (paras 5–6).
  • The respondents shall issue an order of appointment/call letter to the appellant if she is otherwise entitled (para 5).
  • The appellant shall not claim seniority over candidates already appointed (para 5).

Legal Principle Laid Down

Where a recruitment candidate who has cleared all other stages is rejected on medical grounds and credible independent opinions cast doubt on that assessment, the Supreme Court may refer her to an independent expert medical board; if that board certifies her fit, the conclusion of the selection process does not bar relief, though the appointment may be directed without seniority over those already appointed. The order turns on its peculiar facts.

Precedents Relied Upon

  • Order in SLP (Civil) No. 17704/2025 – Followed – medical board constituted in similar circumstances to ascertain a candidate's fitness. Discussed at para 3.

Important Paragraphs of the Judgment

Verbatim extracts from the judgment. For the full text, refer to the judgment PDF below.

Para 2: "The short point which arises for consideration in the present appeal relates to recruitment of the Appellant to the post of Constable Civil Police under U.P. Police Constable Civil Direct Recruitment, 2023."

Para 2: "Same having been rejected, she approached the jurisdictional High Court for a direction to re-conduct the medical examination which came to be dismissed by the impugned order on the ground of selection process having been concluded."

Para 5: "The aforesaid Report would persuade us to accept the plea of the Appellant of having been deprived of her legitimate right for being appointed to the post of Police Constable Civil Police after having successfully cleared all the tests."

Para 5: "... we make it explicitly clear that the Appellant shall not claim seniority over the candidates who have already been appointed till date."

Practical Impact of the Ruling

  • For recruitment candidates: A medical rejection is not the last word where independent specialists dispute it; the Supreme Court may order an expert examination (paras 2–3).
  • For recruiting agencies: Medical boards should record and communicate rejection reasons; here no rejection order was furnished (para 2).
  • For High Courts: Closure of the selection process did not stop the Supreme Court from granting relief in the peculiar facts (paras 2, 5).
  • For selected candidates: Their seniority is protected; the appellant cannot claim seniority over them (para 5).

FAQs on Medical Rejection in UP Police Constable Recruitment

1. What did the Supreme Court decide in Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P.?

It set aside the High Court's order and directed the authorities to issue her appointment order or call letter as Constable Civil Police if she is otherwise entitled (para 5).

2. Why was she rejected earlier?

The medical board on 22.04.2025 and the Division Medical Board on 25.04.2025 declared her unfit on account of a squint (para 2).

3. What did the KGMU medical board find?

Its report dated 16.10.2026 recorded best-corrected vision of 6/6 in both eyes and most other parameters within normal limits (para 4).

4. Will she get seniority from the original recruitment?

No. The Court made it explicit that she shall not claim seniority over candidates already appointed (para 5).

5. Why had the High Court refused relief?

It dismissed her writ petition on the ground that the selection process had concluded (para 2).

Keywords: 2026 INSC 1184, Akanksha Devi v. State of UP, UP Police Constable recruitment 2023, squint eye medical unfit, Rule 15(6)(d) UP Police Rules, KGMU medical board, police recruitment medical examination, appointment without seniority, Justice Aravind Kumar, Supreme Court non-reportable judgment, service law

Related on LegalTaxGuru

Download Judgment PDF – Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P.

Judgment PDF: 2026 INSC 1184 – Akanksha Devi v. State of U.P. & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 14041 of 2026) – Download Judgment PDF

Source: Supreme Court of India (official website).

Share: WhatsApp Facebook

Practitioner Discussion & Analysis

Contribute your legal commentary or cite relevant tribunal precedents
⚖️ Submissions are moderated according to Legal Tax Guru Editorial Guidelines.

Stay Ahead of Tax & Legal Developments

Join 45,000+ Advocates, Chartered Accountants, and Corporate Counsels receiving daily statutory notifications & judicial commentaries.