Quick Answer: Health drink powders such as 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix' are not "non-alcoholic drinks and beverages" under Entry 20(ii) of Schedule II to the M.P. Commercial Tax Act, 1994. Tax is levied on the form of the goods at the time of sale, not on how the consumer later uses them, so these powders fall under the residuary entry at 8%, not 10%. The Supreme Court dismissed the Revenue's appeals.
In Addl. Commr. Commercial Tax & Ors. v. Cadila Health Care Ltd & Anr. (2026 INSC 1078), the Supreme Court held that the taxable event is the sale and the incidence of tax depends on the nature of the goods in the form in which they are sold, so 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix', sold as powder and biscuit, cannot be classified as beverages merely because consumers mix them with milk or water (paras 16–19, 29). A Bench of Justice Manmohan and Justice Arun Palli read the word "beverages" in Entry 20(ii) ejusdem generis with the liquid items listed alongside it, and upheld the Madhya Pradesh High Court's judgment placing the goods under the residuary entry at 8% for Assessment Year 1997-98 (paras 1, 20–24, 31).
Status: Madhya Pradesh High Court's judgment dated 03.08.2011 in W.P. Nos. 3020 of 2003 and 4633 of 2003 upheld; Revenue's appeals dismissed (paras 1, 31).
Headnote: Health Drink Powder Not a Beverage
M.P. Commercial Tax Act, 1994 – Schedule II, Part IV, Entry 20(ii) ("all kinds of non-alcoholic drinks and beverages including syrups, cordials, distilled juices, ark and essences") – Part VII, Entry 1 (residuary entry) – Classification of 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix' – Taxable event – Form of goods at the time of sale – End use irrelevant – Ejusdem generis – Common parlance and functional character tests – Strict construction of taxing statutes – Assessment Year 1997-98.
Held: (i) Taxing statutes are to be strictly construed; nothing can be read into or implied in them, and the plain language governs unless it is ambiguous or absurd (para 15).
(ii) The taxable event is the act of supply, and the incidence of tax is determined by the nature of the goods in the form in which they are sold; the tax authorities must look at what is supplied, not at its end use (paras 16–19).
(iii) The items listed in Entry 20(ii) – syrups, cordials, distilled juices, ark and essences – are all liquids; read ejusdem generis, "beverages" cannot cover goods of a different physical form such as powders (paras 20, 23).
(iv) Entry 20(ii) makes no reference to end use, and the common parlance, functional or basic nature tests cannot be used to import an end-use concept where the entry is clear (paras 21–22).
(v) Goods that do not answer a specific entry fall under the residuary entry and cannot be forced into an inapposite specific entry merely to attract a higher rate of tax (para 24).
(vi) Pioma Industries, S. Samuel M.D. and Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories (2026) are distinguishable; the word "including" in Entry 20(ii) does not make the entry all-encompassing (paras 25–28).
(paras 15–29)
Case Details: Addl. Commr. Commercial Tax v. Cadila Health Care (2026 INSC 1078)
Final Outcome: Appeals dismissed; Madhya Pradesh High Court's judgment upheld; 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix' taxable at 8% under the residuary entry, not at 10% as beverages.
Case: Addl. Commr. Commercial Tax & Ors. v. Cadila Health Care Ltd & Anr.
Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1078
Case No.: Civil Appeal Nos. 9788–9789 of 2013
Court: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction) – Reportable
Date of Decision: 5 October 2026
Bench: Justice Manmohan (author) and Justice Arun Palli
Relevant Acts & Sections: M.P. Commercial Tax Act, 1994 – Sections 2(d) and 9; Schedule II, Part IV, Entry 20(ii) and Part VII, Entry 1 (residuary); M.P. Entry Tax Act, 1976 – Schedule II, Entry 14 and Schedule III (background)
Impugned Order: Madhya Pradesh High Court – judgment dated 03.08.2011 in W.P. Nos. 3020 of 2003 and 4633 of 2003 (para 1)
Counsel: Mr. Akraj Kumar for the appellants (Revenue); Mr. Vivek Sarin, Senior Advocate, for the respondents (paras 6, 12, 30)
Source: Supreme Court of India (official website)
Key Holdings of the Supreme Court
- Taxing statutes must be strictly construed according to their plain language (para 15).
- Tax is levied on the form of the goods at the time of sale; later use by the consumer does not change the taxable event (paras 16–19).
- A powder mix is taxed as a powder; only a ready-to-drink product is taxed as a beverage (para 17).
- All items in Entry 20(ii) are liquids, so "beverages" must be read ejusdem generis and does not include powders (paras 20, 23).
- Entry 20(ii) does not refer to end use, and common parlance or functional tests cannot import an end-use concept where the entry is clear (paras 21–22).
- Goods outside a specific entry fall in the residuary entry and cannot be pushed into a specific entry to attract a higher rate (para 24).
- 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix', sold as powder and biscuit, are not beverages (para 29).
Brief Facts of the Case
Cadila Health Care Ltd manufactured and marketed 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix'. For Assessment Year 1997-98, the Revenue sought to classify them as non-alcoholic drinks and beverages under Entry 20(ii), Part IV, Schedule II of the M.P. Commercial Tax Act, 1994, taxable at 10% (paras 1–3).
The Revenue relied on the graphical representation and instructions on the packs, which asked consumers to dilute the product with milk or water. The respondents argued that the goods were sold across the counter as powder and biscuit, and were taxable at 8% under the residuary entry in Part VII (para 2).
Entry 20(ii) covered "all kinds of non-alcoholic drinks and beverages including syrups, cordials, distilled juices, ark and essences when sold in sealed or capsuled or cork bottles or jars" at 10%, while the residuary entry covered all other goods at 8% (para 3).
The Court also noted the position under the Entry Tax Act, 1976 for the same year, which had three phases: residuary entry at 1% in April 1997, no entry from May to September 1997, and competing Entry 14 (2%) and the residuary entry from October 1997 to March 1998 (para 4).
By judgment dated 03.08.2011 in W.P. Nos. 3020 of 2003 and 4633 of 2003, the Madhya Pradesh High Court upheld the classification of the goods under the residuary entry at 8%. The Revenue appealed (para 1).
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- What is the taxable event, and whether tax is to be levied on the form of the goods at the time of sale or on the end product (para 5(i)).
- Whether 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix' are classifiable as non-alcoholic drinks and beverages or fall under the residuary entry (para 5(ii)).
Court's Findings and Reasoning
Revenue's case (paras 6–11): Counsel argued that taxing entries must be read in their natural sense; that the packs invited consumers to enjoy the product hot or cold with milk or water, presenting it as a health drink; that tea and coffee in powder form are taxed as beverages; and that the common use and functional character, basic nature and common parlance tests pointed to a beverage. Reliance was placed on Atul Glass Industries, Indian Aluminum Cables, Pioma Industries, Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories (2026) and S. Samuel M.D.
Assessee's case (paras 12–14): Senior Counsel argued that under Sections 2(d) and 9, the levy is confined to goods specified in Schedule II; that goods outside a specific entry go to the residuary entry; that Entry 20(ii) makes no reference to use, and end use is irrelevant (Dunlop India); and that under Hamdard Wakf Laboratories (1999) a beverage must be a liquid at the time of the taxable event.
Strict construction (para 15): Relying on Mathuram Agrawal, the Court held that no intention beyond the plain language can be assumed in a taxing statute.
Form at the time of sale (paras 16–19): The taxable event is supply, and tax depends on the form in which the goods are sold. A protein powder is taxed as a powder, while bottled cold coffee or a packaged protein shake is taxed as a beverage. The consumer may mix a powder into a drink or use it to make barfi, but that does not change the taxable event (Carrier Aircon).
Entry 20(ii) covers liquids only (paras 20–23): All items enumerated with "beverages" are liquids capable of being bottled and consumed in liquid form. The entry classifies goods by physical form, not end use. The common parlance, functional and basic nature tests cannot be used to import end use where the entry is clear, and under ejusdem generis "beverages" takes its meaning from the associated liquid items.
Residuary entry applies (para 24): The Court agreed that goods not answering a specific entry must fall in the residuary entry and cannot be forced into an inapposite entry merely to attract a higher rate.
Precedents distinguished (paras 25–28): In Pioma Industries, the matter was remanded without deciding whether Rasna was a beverage, and the Kerala entry expressly included powders and concentrates – which the Madhya Pradesh legislature chose not to do. S. Samuel M.D. concerned whether tea is food, not whether tea leaves are a beverage. In Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories (2026), the sharbat was a liquid, and "including" cannot mean "all encompassing".
Final Outcome and Directions
- 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix', existing as powder and biscuit at the time of sale, do not fall within "beverages" under Entry 20(ii) (para 29).
- The Madhya Pradesh High Court's judgment classifying them under the residuary entry at 8% is upheld (paras 1, 29).
- The Revenue's appeals are dismissed; pending applications disposed of (paras 31–32).
Legal Principle Laid Down
For sales tax classification, the taxable event is the sale, and goods must be classified by their form at the time of sale, not by the end use to which the consumer may later put them. An entry for "non-alcoholic drinks and beverages" whose enumerated items are all liquids must be read ejusdem generis and does not cover powders or biscuits used to prepare drinks, unless the legislature expressly includes them. Goods that do not answer a specific entry fall in the residuary entry and cannot be forced into a specific entry merely to attract a higher rate of tax.
Precedents Relied Upon
- Mathuram Agrawal v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (1999) 8 SCC 667 – Relied upon – taxing statutes to be construed by their plain language. Discussed at para 15.
- Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi v. Carrier Aircon Ltd., (2006) 5 SCC 596 – Relied upon – end use by itself does not determine classification. Discussed at para 16.
- Pioma Industries v. State of Kerala, (2008) 12 SCC 695 – Distinguished – matter remanded; Kerala entry expressly included powders. Discussed at paras 9, 25–26.
- S. Samuel M.D., Harrisons Malayalam v. Union of India, (2004) 1 SCC 256 – Distinguished – concerned whether tea is food; no competing entries. Discussed at paras 11, 25, 27.
- Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories v. Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P., 2026 SCC OnLine SC 306 – Distinguished – sharbat was in liquid form; "including" is not all-encompassing. Discussed at paras 10, 28.
- Hamdard Wakf Laboratories v. Collector of Central Excise, (1999) 6 SCC 617 – Cited by the respondents – beverages are liquids for drinking. Discussed at para 14.
- Dunlop India Ltd. v. Union of India, (1976) 2 SCC 241 – Cited by the respondents – end use irrelevant for classification. Discussed at para 13.
- Atul Glass Industries v. Collector of Excise, (1986) 3 SCC 480; Indian Aluminium Cables Ltd. v. Union of India, (1985) 3 SCC 284 – Cited by the Revenue; tests held inapplicable to import end use here. Discussed at paras 7–8, 22.
Important Paragraphs of the Judgment
Verbatim extracts from the judgment. For the full text, refer to the judgment PDF below.
Para 15: "It is settled law that taxing statutes are to be strictly construed."
Para 16: "This Court is further of the opinion that the taxable event is the act of supply and the incidence of taxation is determined by the nature of the good in the form in which it is sold."
Para 17: "The tax authorities are bound to look at what is supplied and not at what is the 'end use' of the good."
Para 22: "This Court is of the opinion that common parlance test, functional test or basic nature test cannot be applied to import end use concept to override or bypass explicit or implicit statutory guidance, particularly, where the language of the entry is clear and unambiguous-like in the present appeals."
Para 24: "They cannot be forced into an inapposite specific entry merely to attract a higher rate of tax."
Para 29: "While it is possible that the goods may ultimately be used to make a beverage or a solid preparation, at the point of taxable event, they remain in powder form. Consequently, they do not fall within the expression 'beverage'."
Practical Impact of the Ruling
- For manufacturers of health drink powders: Powders and mixes sold in dry form cannot be taxed as beverages merely because the pack instructs consumers to mix them with milk or water (paras 17–19, 29).
- For tax authorities: Classification must follow the form of goods at the time of sale; end use and marketing imagery cannot override a clear entry (paras 17, 21–22).
- For tax practitioners: Where a specific entry enumerates only liquids, ejusdem generis can be invoked to keep dry goods out of it (paras 20, 23).
- For classification disputes generally: The common parlance and functional tests yield to clear statutory language, and the residuary entry applies when no specific entry fits (paras 22, 24).
- For legislatures: If powders and concentrates are meant to be taxed as beverages, the entry must say so expressly, as the Kerala entry in Pioma Industries did (para 26).
FAQs on Classification of Health Drink Powders
1. What did the Supreme Court hold in Addl. Commr. Commercial Tax v. Cadila Health Care?
It held that 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix', sold as powder and biscuit, are not beverages under Entry 20(ii) and fall under the residuary entry at 8%, and dismissed the Revenue's appeals (paras 29, 31).
2. What is the taxable event for classification?
The act of supply or sale; tax depends on the nature of the goods in the form in which they are sold (paras 16, 19).
3. Does the consumer's end use matter?
No. Mixing the powder with milk or water to make a drink does not alter the taxable event, and Entry 20(ii) does not refer to end use (paras 18, 21).
4. Why was "beverages" read narrowly?
Because all items listed with it in Entry 20(ii) are liquids, and under the rule of ejusdem generis the general word takes its meaning from the specific words (paras 20, 23).
5. Why was Pioma Industries (Rasna) not followed?
That case was remanded without deciding classification, and the Kerala entry expressly included powders and concentrates, unlike Entry 20(ii) (para 26).
Keywords: 2026 INSC 1078, Addl. Commr. Commercial Tax v. Cadila Health Care, GRD Powder, health drink powder not beverage, M.P. Commercial Tax Act 1994, Entry 20(ii), residuary entry, taxable event form of goods at sale, end use irrelevant, ejusdem generis, common parlance test, sales tax classification, Justice Manmohan, Supreme Court reportable judgment, tax lawyer
Related on LegalTaxGuru
Download Judgment PDF – Addl. Commr. Commercial Tax v. Cadila Health Care
Source: Supreme Court of India (official website).