In the legal system, the terms reportable judgments and non reportable judgments usually relate to which specific judgments should be published and made available as examples for future cases. The distinction between these two categories of judgments lies in their impact on the development of legal principles and the guidance they provide to other courts and legal professionals.
Courts consider Reportable judgments significant and important for establishing or clarifying legal principles. These judgments set new precedents or contribute significantly to the interpretation of existing laws. When a judgment is labelled as reportable.
This implies that legal professionals, researchers, and the public should publish it in legal databases, law reports, and other sources to make it accessible.. These judgments have a broader impact beyond the specific case they address and serve as a guide for similar cases in the future.
On the other hand, the court considers non reportable judgements as less significant or having limited relevance to broader legal principles.
These judgements might deal:-
While they hold legal validity and importance for the parties involved in the case at hand. They do not carry the same weight as reportable judgments when it comes to shaping future legal interpretations.
The distinction between Reportable and Non Reportable judgments serves several purposes-
Precedent | Legal precedents established by reportable judgments guide the decisions of lower courts in similar cases. They contribute to the consistency and predictability of the legal system. |
Legal Development | Reportable Judgments play a role in the development of law by addressing novel legal issues or providing fresh interpretations of existing laws |
Transparency |
|
Efficiency | Non Reportable Judgments allow courts to efficiently handle routine cases without creating unnecessary legal precedent. |
Focus on Important Issues | Distinguishing between Reportable and Non-Reportable Judgments helps the legal system prioritize cases of greater importance. |
Deciding whether judgments are Reportable or Non-Reportable can differ among jurisdictions and courts. Some courts follow clear rules, while others leave it to the judges’ judgment.
By maintaining consistency in legal interpretation and application Reportable judgements serve as a crucial source of guidance for upcoming cases. Reportable judgments significant and important for establishing or clarifying legal principles. The recognition of their importance within the framework of the Indian Constitution underscores their role in shaping legal precedent. The judiciary must issue reportable judgments to ensure fairness and consistency in delivering justice.
Interest on Loan for Purchasing Agricutural Land not Allowable U/s 36 (III) of Income Tax…
जीएसटी अपडेट (हिन्दी) पत्रिका ||Date of Pub.:- 14.05.2024 भाग -III ( अप्रैल 2024) Also Subscription…
WHAT IS GST COUNCIL AND ITS FUNCTION? The GST Council is a constitutional body and…
E GST Magazine Hindi or English Also Subscription Option Available For Online Payment Subscription Charges…
"Supreme Court of India: The Honorable Supreme Court has acknowledged that the burden of proving…
महत्वपूर्ण अंतिम तिथि Important Due Dates 10th मार्च 2024 जीएसटीआर-7 में काटे गये और जमा…